349. How to Keep the Holiday Shopping Momentum after BFCM

When it comes to planning and strategizing for Q4, Black Friday weekend typically gets all the attention, and that makes sense… It is the biggest shopping weekend of the season. 

But, holiday shopping doesn’t stop after Cyber Monday. In fact, you have a solid 2 weeks of prime shopping time after that. 

Whether it’s because consumers shopped mostly for themselves on Black Friday weekend or because there were a bunch of random people added to their list, december is not a time to tap out. 

There’s still money on the table and I want you to grab it before your customers start blowing their budgets somewhere else. 

Prefer to listen to the episode? Click here.

The Shipping Cut-Off Is Your Secret Weapon

The number one urgency lever you have in your favor is the standard shipping cut-off. This typically falls somewhere around December 14th which is conveniently free shipping day. 

In all your holiday marketing during this time, you’ll want to make sure you’re super clear of the date and time they need to order by to get their items in time for the holidays. 

Now, if you are taking time away from the business, or you’re a handmade brand with longer lead times, your shipping cut off might be earlier, that’s okay. Use the same strategy, but on your own timeline. 

One of my favorite ways to drive this message home with a countdown email series, leaning on subject lines to create urgency. Something like “3 days left for holiday delivery” – simple, effective and impossible to ignore. Run that for a 3 or 4 day period leading up to your cut-off. 

Then, repeat the process for expedited shipping options – 3-day, 2-day, and overnight. You’ll be surprised what people are willing to spend on shipping when they’re down to the wire.

Just make sure you’re crystal clear about your time cut-offs — including time zones. I’ve had people place an order on a Friday night with overnight shipping and then get mad it didn’t show up Saturday morning. Don’t assume people know how shipping works. 

Be upfront about the latest time an order can be placed to ensure it leaves your warehouse the same day. 

For example, if you want to guarantee delivery on Monday December 22nd, and your carrier pickup happen at 1PM, you’ll want to tell your customers to order by Friday December 19th at 10AM Pacific Time. 

You want to make sure you’ve built in enough time to process and ship those orders. And notice –  I gave myself a cushion. I’m using Monday December 22nd as the final delivery for Christmas, instead of the 23rd. 

Always leave yourself a little breathing room because when shipping delays happen, and they will, customers won’t blame the carrier, they’ll blame you.  

And don’t be shy about sharing and repeating these shipping cut off details. 

If you’re worried about annoying people – which you shouldn’t be, because most will just ignore you – you can always exclude recent buyers from your cut-off emails. Create a segment of anyone that’s ordered in the last X days, I usually do in the last 7 to 14 days, and you’re good to go. 

Get Creative With Small But Mighty Promos

Another great way to capture attention in December is with small but mighty promos. Line it up with the countdown to the standard shipping cut-off and you’ve natural excitement and urgency. 

You don’t need to go as hard as you did for Black Friday, in fact, please don’t. BFCM should still feel special. But a creative or targeted promo works great here. 

That might look like a BOGO or a Buy More Save More if you did a straight discount for Black Friday. It might look like a limited time bundle. 

At a minimum you’ll want to run this promo the weekend of free shipping day since that’s the last standard shipping weekend of the shopping season, but you can extend it earlier into the week before as well. Maybe you want to do it the entire week, maybe you mirror my recommended structure for BFCM which starts on Wednesday evening. 

If you have a brick + mortar or in-person pickup, you could also do something special on the last weekend before Christmas since you don’t have to accommodate shipping times. 

Spotlight Holiday Products & Gift Cards

If you have anything remotely holiday-related – ornaments, specific holiday scented candles, sometimes even just your winter collection items, now is the time to shout about them. 

My goal is always to sell through the majority if not all seasonal items by that standard shipping cut-off, otherwise you’ll likely get stuck with them. 

Work them into your promotion, or just make the promotion only on those items. 

As we get past the standard shipping cut-off, that’s when you want to focus heavily on gift cards. It’s a good idea to promote them throughout the holiday shopping season of course, but those last few days when it’s truly down to the wire for online shopping, let gift cards be the star of the show. 

So remember — Black Friday might get all the attention, but it’s not the end of the game. You’ve got two solid weeks left to make an impact, move that inventory, and pad your year-end numbers.

Use your shipping cut-offs, small but mighty promos, and gift cards to bring in that final cash influx so you can enjoy the rest of the season. Stay visible, stay consistent, and remind your customers you’re still here with gifts they’ll actually love.

Listen to the Episode

Resources Mentioned:

Holiday Podcast Episodes

Gift Guide Glow Up

Holiday Content Bundle

Q4 Badassery | Formally Badass Holiday Planning Guide

Jessica Totillo Coster your eCommerce & Email Marketing Strategist

Hi, I'm Jessica

eCommerce & email marketing strategist with 25+ years in retail, including running a 7-figure store as the only employee. I teach product-based business owners how to do less and make more.

Read More About Me ⟶

Quick Links

Stop Doing things that Don't Make You Money

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Free Resource Library

Get access to strategy guides to grow your traffic, sales, and profit + all my favorite apps and tech tools!

Post
Categories

This post may contain affiliate links. if you make a purchase with one of my affiliate links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.

About the Author

Jessica Totillo Coster

Jessica Totillo Coster is an eCommerce and email marketing strategist for product-based business owners. She spent 25+ years in retail, including three years as the sole employee running a 7-figure eCommerce store, where she generated $300K+ per year from email alone. Before that, she built a brick-and-mortar boutique that hit $650K in its first year. She founded eCommerce Badassery to teach store owners the strategies that actually create move revenue and profit… not more tactics to pile on. Her flagship course, Email Badassery, walks students through building a full suite of automated email flows that drive consistent sales without the burnout. Members looking for ongoing support join The Lounge, her membership community where she helps established store owners pinpoint the exact metric worth focusing on next and gives them the strategy to make progress. Her philosophy: do less, make more.

Featured In

klaviyo logo
drip beyond the inbox podcast logo
okendo logo
marketing impact academy by Chalene Johnson logo
Flourish & Thrive Academy by Tracy Matthews logo

You May Also Like

direct
access

eCommerce Support & Community

The Lounge

Ongoing support for eCommerce business owners.

Know exactly what to do next in your business based on your data, boost sales with our marketing blueprints, up level your skills in analytics, ads, SEO, email and more.

Get direct access to your hosts and a community of other product-based business owners.

It’s basically the best damn place on the Internet for eCommerce entrepreneurs.

The-Lounge-eCommerce-Marketing-Membership
haute-stock-styled-stock-photo-subscription-editors-note-final-3-crp.jpg

About Our Audience

  • eCommerce business owners selling a physical product on their own website (Shopify + Klaviyo users)
  • Soloprenuers or less than 25 on their team
  • All revenue ranges, up to multi 7-figures
  • Mostly female

Who We're Looking For

  • Subject matter experts in eCommerce & Physical Product Marketing (ex. Social Media, Public Relations, Website Conversion, Copywriters)
  • Apps or SaaS platforms that can share marketing strategies that work even without their product.

Who We're NOT Looking For

  • Strategies to build ONLY a marketplace business
  • Strategies for building service-based businesses or SaaS Platforms
  • Agency owners who only work with large budget businesses
  • Service providers for coaches or consultants