One of the most common struggles product-based business owners have, especially during the holiday shopping season, is figuring out how to show up consistently through the rest of the year without saying the same thing over and over again.
This can be especially difficult if you have a small product assortment or you don’t release a ton of holiday-specific products.
And while you can certainly lean on traditional holiday messaging like gifts for her, him, price points, stocking stuffers, etc. sometimes you just want a more creative way to position your products to help potential customers and gift givers see them in a new light.
So, today I just wanted to chat through some examples to get those creative wheels turning. One caveat before we start. Please don’t take this episode as a sign you need to revamp your marketing strategy, or re-organize your gift guides. That’s not my intention at all, and in a lot of cases, the more “boring” your gift guide categories, the better they are for long-term SEO.
Think of these more as ways to talk about your products in email, on social media, paid ads, that sort of thing. That doesn’t mean they can’t be gift guide categories if it makes sense for your business, just that it doesn’t have to be.
PREFER TO LISTEN TO THIS EPISODE? CLICK HERE
Why Would Someone Buy Your Product as a Gift
So, the first step is to think about what are all the different reasons someone would buy this product as a gift. Because the more connections you can make between your product and the person your customer is shopping for, the easier you make their buying decision.
Think about your own gift shopping.
Sometimes we know exactly what we want to buy someone. Maybe your partner has been talking about a specific grill accessory for the last few months. That’s easy. Add to cart and they’re handled.
But a lot of the time, we just know we need a gift.
It could be a gift for your sister-in-law, a secret santa gift, or a friend that always seems to buy everything they want for themselves. That’s my father-in-law for sure.
That’s where the positioning can do a lot of the heavy lifting for your customers.
Instead of waiting for them to look at one of your products and figure out who in their life might want it, you can make that connection for them.
Position Your Products Around Personality
One of the more fun ways to approach this is to match your products to different personalities or identities.
And there are SO many directions you can take this.
You could match your products to Zodiac signs. What are you buying the Scorpio versus the Gemini versus the Taurus in your life? This is one of my favorites and is always a hit. Lounge Members, you have an AI prompt to help you pair your products to Zodiac signs in the workshops + guests section.
You could do Myers-Briggs types, Enneagram numbers, love languages, or whatever personality thing your particular customer is into.
But it doesn’t even have to be an official personality type. You could have gifts for:
- the homebody.
- The person who is always cold.
- The friend who always has snacks in her purse.
- The person whose emotional support water bottle goes everywhere with her.
- The hostess.
- The maximalist.
- The clean freak.
- The person who has 700 plants in their house.
And as you’re thinking through these, I want you to get more specific than you normally would.
“Gifts for the homebody” is fine. But “gifts for the friend who would rather cancel plans and watch Friends for the 700th time” paints a much clearer picture. The more your customer can immediately picture a specific person in their life, the better.
Because ultimately, what we want them to think is, “Oh my God, that is SO Sarah.” Once they have that thought, you’ve already gotten them one step closer to making the purchase.
Position Your Products Around the Relationship
You can do something similar based on the relationship your customer has with the person they’re buying for.
And again, we can get way more interesting than gifts for Mom, gifts for Dad, gifts for your husband, whatever.
Think about the actual dynamics people have with the people in their lives.
- What do you buy for the sister who steals all your shit anyway?
- What do you buy for your work bestie who knows entirely too much about your personal life?
- What do you buy for the friend who always shows up with a bottle of wine when you’ve had a shitty week?
- What do you buy for your mother-in-law when you’re still trying to impress her?
- What do you buy for the person who always says, “Don’t get me anything,” but you both know damn well you’re still getting them something?
There are so many little relationship dynamics you can play with here, and those can make your marketing feel a lot more personal.
And obviously, your version of this is going to depend on your brand and your customer.
If your brand has a little more edge or humor, you can have a lot of fun with this.
If your brand is more sentimental, maybe you lean into the relationships in a completely different way.
- Maybe it’s about the friend who has been there through every version of you.
- The mom who still answers every time you call even though you’re 42 years old and should probably know how to handle this shit yourself.
- The person you don’t get to see as often as you’d like.
The strategy is the same. You’re giving the product context.
And that context helps the customer understand why this particular thing makes sense for this particular person.
Position Your Products Around the Situation
You can also think about the situation your customer is shopping for.
This is where some of those more traditional categories like hostess gifts or Secret Santa gifts can come in, but again, I want you to think beyond the obvious labels.
There are a lot of different situations your customer is going to find themselves in over the next few months.
Maybe they’re going to a holiday party and don’t want to show up empty-handed. Maybe their office is doing a gift exchange with a $25 limit. Maybe their kid came home on December 18th and casually informed them they need gifts for three teachers by tomorrow. Maybe somebody unexpectedly gave them a gift and now they’re scrambling because they didn’t buy that person anything.
And depending on what you sell, there may be really specific situations that make sense for your products.
- If you sell food, maybe it’s what you bring to the family gathering when you absolutely do not cook.
- If you sell skincare or bath products, maybe it’s what you give the person who is hosting 14 people for Christmas and is going to need to lock themselves in the bathroom for 45 minutes when everyone leaves.
- If you sell jewelry, maybe it’s the gift for someone you want to give something meaningful to without having to figure out their clothing size.
And this is where knowing your customer really matters.
- What are they actually doing during the holidays?
- Where are they going?
- Who are they seeing?
- What are they stressing about?
- What are the little annoying things they have to deal with?
Those are all opportunities to make your products more relevant.
Position Around the Feeling or Experience
Another way to approach this is to think about what your product actually gives someone beyond the physical product itself.
If you sell a candle, technically you sell wax in a jar.
But depending on the candle, you might actually be selling cozy Christmas morning, a house that smells amazing before guests arrive, or 20 minutes of peace and quiet after the kids go to bed.
If you sell a really nice robe, maybe you’re selling permission to spend the entire day after Christmas on the couch.
If you sell a nostalgic candy box, maybe you’re selling the experience of opening it with your siblings and fighting over who gets the same candy you all fought over when you were kids.
If you sell something funny, maybe the whole point of the gift is watching the person open it.
And when you start thinking this way, you’ll probably find that some of the products you didn’t initially think of as super giftable actually have a lot more potential than you realized.
Practical products are a great example of this.
A water bottle doesn’t necessarily feel like the most exciting Christmas gift in the world when I just say “water bottle.” But maybe it’s the gift for your friend who carries three beverages with her everywhere she goes. Or the person who made “drink more water” their New Year’s resolution for the last six years.
Now we’ve got something to talk about. And that’s the point of this strategy. You’re looking for more entry points into the conversation.
You Don’t Have to Turn All of These Into Gift Guides
Now, I know as I’m giving you all these examples, your brain might immediately start creating 27 new collections for your website. As I mentioned earlier, you don’t have to do that.
You certainly can create a gift guide or collection if there’s a strong enough angle and you think it would be helpful for your customer.
But these positioning ideas can be used in pretty much any of your holiday marketing.
- Maybe one becomes an email.
- Maybe you take five of your products and create a social carousel matching each one to a Zodiac sign.
- Maybe one becomes the hook for an ad.
- Maybe you create a bundle.
And don’t be afraid to feature the same products more than once.
I think we forget sometimes that our customers are not sitting at home with a spreadsheet tracking which products we featured in every email.
They are not saying, “Excuse me, Jessica. You showed me this candle on November 12th and now here it is again on November 27th. How dare you.”
They probably don’t remember. And even if they do remember seeing the product, they may not have had a reason to buy it the first time.
Maybe the first time you showed them the candle, you positioned it as a hostess gift and they didn’t need a hostess gift. But two weeks later you call it the perfect gift for their friend who treats her house like a sanctuary, and now somebody immediately comes to mind.
That’s why changing the positioning matters. You’re giving the same customer another opportunity to see themselves, or someone they love, in the product.
Your Holiday Positioning Exercise
So here’s what I want you to do after you finish this episode.
Pick three to five products that you know you’re going to be talking about a lot over the next few months.
Maybe they’re your best sellers. Maybe they have great margins. Maybe you have a shit ton of inventory you need to move. Whatever makes the most sense for your business.
And for each one, come up with at least five different reasons someone might buy it.
Think about personality, relationships, situations, the feeling and the experience.
Think about those very specific people where your customer is going to hear the description and immediately know exactly who you’re talking about.
If you’re an AI user, you can even ask for a little help making those connections.
And then look at your holiday marketing calendar and start plugging those ideas in. You don’t need a new product every time you send an email. You don’t need a new promotion every time you want people to pay attention. Sometimes you just need to show them the same thing from a different angle.
And during a season where you’re going to be talking about your products a LOT, having more ways to talk about what you already sell makes your life a hell of a lot easier.









